The Commercial Machinery
Knowing the chemistry tells you what is possible. Knowing the contracts tells you what will actually arrive, at what price, and when.
Ore to Vehicle · Part 4 — Structure and Commerce · Chapter 12 · 17 min read
Knowing the chemistry tells you what is possible. Knowing the contracts tells you what will actually arrive, at what price, and when.
4
Materials you can properly hedge
4
You cannot
13 yr
Gap between a mine and a gigafactory
3–6 mo
Metal financed as working capital
12.1 — How each material is priced
| Material | Price mechanism | Venue | Can you hedge it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Copper | Exchange-traded | LME · COMEX · SHFE | Yes — deep, liquid, decades of history |
| Aluminium | Exchange-traded | LME · SHFE | Yes |
| Nickel | Exchange-traded, plus assessed sulfate premium | LME · SHFE | Partly — LME nickel and battery-grade sulfate can diverge |
| Silver | Exchange-traded | COMEX · LBMA | Yes |
| Lithium | Mostly assessed; growing futures | Fastmarkets · Benchmark · Argus · GFEX | Barely — most contracts reference assessments |
| Cobalt | Assessed, thin LME contract | Fastmarkets · LME | Poorly |
| Graphite | Fully assessed | Fastmarkets · Benchmark | No |
| Rare earths | Fully assessed, plus ex-China premium | Asian Metal · Argus | No |
12.2 — What you can hedge and what you cannot
Important
Read the right-hand column as a risk register. A cell manufacturer can hedge its copper and aluminium and cannot hedge its lithium, graphite or magnets.
That is not a market inefficiency waiting to be arbitraged; it follows from the products being non-fungible. “Battery-grade graphite” is a specification with a coating recipe, not a commodity, and you cannot write a deliverable futures contract on it.
Consequence: those exposures have to be managed with inventory, contract structure and supplier diversity instead of with financial instruments.
12.3 — Contract structures you will encounter
| Structure | What it is | Why it exists |
|---|---|---|
| Offtake agreement | A buyer commits to purchase a fixed volume or percentage of output for a set term, at a formula price — usually an index minus a discount. | It gives the producer bankability and the buyer security, and it is how nearly all new mine and converter capacity is financed. |
| Prepayment | The buyer pays in advance against future deliveries. | Cheap capital for the producer, price and counterparty risk for the buyer. Common in cobalt and lithium during expansion phases — financing disguised as procurement. |
| Streaming and royalties | An investor funds a mine in exchange for the right to buy a byproduct — usually silver or gold — at a deep fixed discount for the mine’s life. | It is precisely how silver’s byproduct nature from chapter 4 gets financialised. |
| Tolling and conversion | The material owner keeps title and pays a converter a fee to process it. | Common in lithium — spodumene tolled into carbonate — and in magnets. Useful because it separates the metal price risk from the processing margin. |
12.4 — The mismatch that causes every cycle
Technical framing
A gigafactory can be built in two to three years. The copper mine that supplies it takes fifteen or more from discovery to first production.
Every commodity cycle in this industry is that gap expressing itself — capacity arrives after the price signal that justified it has already reversed.
12.5 — Working capital — the part that surprises manufacturers
Between paying for concentrate and being paid for cells, a battery manufacturer typically finances three to six months of metal. On a plant consuming a few thousand tonnes of cathode material a year, that is a large permanent claim on the balance sheet that has nothing to do with equipment.
12.5.1 — Terms worth negotiating hard
Quotational period — which month’s average price applies. Provisional versus final invoicing. Who carries price risk between shipment and assay.
Two more practical items. Assay exchange: buyer and seller each assay the cargo, and if results differ beyond a tolerance an umpire lab decides — standard, and worth budgeting time for. Incoterms: CIF versus FOB moves not just freight cost but insurance and the moment title passes, which decides who eats a loss at sea.
Quick check: test yourself
1.Why is there no futures contract for battery-grade graphite?
Show answer
2.A cell plant signs a five-year offtake for spodumene at index minus a discount. What has it actually bought?
Show answer
3.Why does this industry overshoot so reliably in both directions?
Show answer
Chapter summary
- ✓Copper, aluminium, nickel and silver trade on exchanges; lithium, cobalt, graphite and rare earths are assessed.
- ✓The hedgeable/non-hedgeable split is a risk register, and it follows from non-fungibility rather than from market immaturity.
- ✓Offtake, prepayment, streaming and tolling are the four structures that actually finance and move this material.
- ✓Build times differ by an order of magnitude across the chain, and that gap is every commodity cycle in the industry.
- ✓A manufacturer finances three to six months of metal permanently — a balance-sheet item with nothing to do with equipment.
Frequently asked questions
Which battery materials can actually be hedged?+
Copper, aluminium and silver, on deep and liquid exchange contracts with decades of history. Nickel partly — LME nickel trades, but battery-grade sulfate carries an assessed premium that can diverge. Lithium barely, since most contracts reference assessments even though GFEX futures have grown. Cobalt poorly, on a thin LME contract. Graphite and rare earths not at all. That right-hand column is a risk register: a cell manufacturer can hedge its copper and cannot hedge its magnets.
Why can you not write a futures contract on battery-grade graphite?+
Because it is not fungible. "Battery-grade graphite" is a specification with a coating recipe, not a commodity — the coating controls SEI formation and first-cycle efficiency and is where most of the proprietary know-how sits. A deliverable futures contract needs a standard grade that any seller can satisfy, and that does not exist. The consequence is that these exposures must be managed with inventory, contract structure and supplier diversity rather than with instruments.
What contract structures are used in these chains?+
Offtake agreements, where a buyer commits to a fixed volume or percentage of output at a formula price, usually an index minus a discount — this is how nearly all new mine and converter capacity is financed. Prepayment, which is financing disguised as procurement. Streaming and royalties, where an investor funds a mine in exchange for the right to buy a byproduct at a deep fixed discount for the mine’s life — precisely how silver’s byproduct nature gets financialised. And tolling, where the material owner keeps title and pays a converter a fee, which usefully separates metal price risk from processing margin.
Why does this industry have such violent cycles?+
Because the stages have wildly different build times and demand signals propagate up the chain far faster than supply can respond down it. A gigafactory takes two to three years; the copper mine that supplies it takes sixteen from discovery to first production. That thirteen-year gap is every commodity cycle in this industry expressing itself — capacity arrives after the price signal that justified it has already reversed.
Reviewed by
Ore to Vehicle is an original educational series on the battery and EV materials supply chain. Country shares, grades, prices and policy status are approximate, drawn from public reporting as of mid-2026, and move year to year — treat them as orders of magnitude rather than as a ledger, and verify before relying on them commercially.